Case studies
Cases.
Public-record case studies organized by kind. Court records, inquiries, House and Senate hearings, research studies, staff reports, regulatory reviews, and oversight reconstructions.
Court and trial records already on the public site.
Lindsay Clancy — the record and the campaign
·14 minBoth sides agree Lindsay Clancy killed her three children. The live dispute is criminal responsibility. A public campaign treated the trial as a cause. An extreme register treated her admission as a frame-up. Friday 28 August ended with no verdict; the jury returns Monday 31 August.
Trial days (23)
- Lindsay Clancy — 27 July 20263 min
- Lindsay Clancy — 29 July 20262 min
- Lindsay Clancy — 30 July 20262 min
- Lindsay Clancy — 31 July 20262 min
- Lindsay Clancy — 3 August 20261 min
- Lindsay Clancy — 4 August 20262 min
- Lindsay Clancy — 5 August 20262 min
- Lindsay Clancy — 6 August 20263 min
- Lindsay Clancy — 7 August 20261 min
- Lindsay Clancy — 10 August 20262 min
- Lindsay Clancy — 11 August 20262 min
- Lindsay Clancy — 12 August 20262 min
- Lindsay Clancy — 13 August 20262 min
- Lindsay Clancy — 17 August 20262 min
- Lindsay Clancy — 18 August 20265 min
- Lindsay Clancy — 19 August 20263 min
- Lindsay Clancy — 20 August 20263 min
- Lindsay Clancy — 21 August 20262 min
- Lindsay Clancy — 24 August 20262 min
- Lindsay Clancy — 25 August 20264 min
- Lindsay Clancy — 26 August 20263 min
- Lindsay Clancy — 27 August 20265 min
- Lindsay Clancy — 28 August 20262 min
Official inquiries and inquest records.
Named sitting of a House committee. Reconstructed from the public hearing record.
Weaponization subcommittee opens — 9 February 2023
·2 minThe opening hearing of the House Select Subcommittee on the Weaponization of the Federal Government on 9 February 2023 — what the inaugural session established about scope, jurisdiction, and investigative intent, what remained contested between majority and minority, and where the public record stops. A signed reconstruction from widely reported proceedings.
The Twitter Files hearing — 9 March 2023
·5 minThe House Weaponization Select Subcommittee hearing of 9 March 2023 — what the public record establishes about federal content flagging, what remains contested between majority and minority, and where the evidence runs out. A reconstruction from publicly documented exchanges, not a transcript archive.
FBI whistleblowers — 18 May 2023
·6 minThe House Weaponization Subcommittee hearing of 18 May 2023 examining FBI whistleblower testimony about alleged retaliation, politicization, and internal bureau practices — what the public record establishes, what remained contested between majority and minority, and where the evidence runs out. A signed reconstruction from widely reported proceedings.
The Twitter Files, one year later — 30 November 2023
·5 minThe House Weaponization Subcommittee hearing of 30 November 2023 — what the one-year follow-on to the Twitter Files hearing established, what remained contested between majority and minority, and where the record stops. A signed reconstruction from public proceedings, not an archived transcript.
Confronting the Scourge — 14 November 2023
·16 minWhat did the 14 November 2023 subcommittee hearing establish about campus antisemitism three weeks after October 7th, what witnesses testified about DEI offices and Title VI enforcement, and what remained contested?
Holding Campus Leaders Accountable — 5 December 2023
·7 minThe 5 December 2023 House hearing on campus antisemitism — what the testimony established about university responses to October 7th aftermath, what the widely reported exchange about genocide revealed, and what remained unresolved. A reconstruction from public record, not a transcript repository.
Columbia in Crisis — 17 April 2024
·7 minWhat did the 17 April 2024 House Education and the Workforce hearing establish about Columbia's response to campus antisemitism after October 7, and what remained contested?
Calling for Accountability — 23 May 2024
·12 minWhat did the 23 May 2024 House Education and the Workforce hearing establish about Northwestern, Rutgers, and UCLA responses to campus antisemitism and encampments, and what remained contested?
Fauci before the House — 3 June 2024
·5 minThe House hearing of 3 June 2024 examining Dr. Anthony Fauci's testimony on COVID-19 origins, public health guidance, and pandemic response — what the public record establishes, what remained contested between majority and minority, and where the evidence runs out. A signed reconstruction from widely reported proceedings.
Beyond the Ivy League — 7 May 2025
·16 minWhat did the 7 May 2025 House Education and Workforce hearing establish about Haverford, DePaul, and Cal Poly responses to campus antisemitism, and what remained contested?
Faculty, Funding, and Ideology — 15 July 2025
·15 minWhat did the 15 July 2025 House Education and the Workforce hearing establish about Georgetown, CUNY, and UC Berkeley responses to antisemitism, and what remained contested about faculty conduct, foreign funding transparency, and DEI policy impacts?
Confronting Union Antisemitism — 9 July 2024
·21 minWhat the 9 July 2024 House hearing established about labor union conduct toward Jewish workers post-October 7, and what institutional questions remained unresolved.
Unmasking Union Antisemitism — 9 September 2025
·19 minWhat the 9 September 2025 House hearing established about labor unions and workplace antisemitism, and what claims remained contested.
From Playground to Classroom — 10 September 2025
·20 minWhat did the 10 September 2025 House Early Childhood subcommittee hearing establish about antisemitism in K-12 schools, and what remained contested?
Bad Medicine — 20 May 2026
·28 minWhat did the 20 May 2026 House HELP subcommittee hearing establish about antisemitism in health care and medical unions, and what remained contested?
Training Activists, Not Physicians — 14 July 2026
·17 minWhat did the 14 July 2026 House Education and Workforce hearing establish about DEI, antisemitism, and medical-school training at UCLA, UCSF, and the University of Illinois, and what remained contested?
Speech or Silence — 29 April 2026
·27 minWhat did the 29 April 2026 House Education and Workforce hearing establish about First Amendment protections, student association rights, and campus speech restrictions at public universities, and what remained contested?
Garland, the NSBA letter, and school-board parents — 21 October 2021
·7 minThe House Judiciary hearing of 21 October 2021 examining Attorney General Merrick Garland's 4 October memo directing DOJ and FBI coordination on school-board threats — what the hearing record established about the NSBA letter, the memo's scope and basis, and what remained contested between majority and minority readings.
IRS whistleblowers — 2023
·7 minThe 2023 IRS whistleblower hearings examining Gary Shapley and Joseph Ziegler testimony about the Hunter Biden tax investigation — what the public record establishes about investigative handling, prosecutorial decisions, and alleged interference, what remained contested between majority and minority, and where the evidence runs out. A signed reconstruction from widely reported proceedings.
Mayorkas impeachment hearings — January 2024
·8 minThe January 2024 House Homeland Security Committee impeachment hearings examining Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas's handling of border security — what the public record establishes about the constitutional standard, the allegations, the majority and minority cases, and where the evidence and legal questions remained contested. A signed reconstruction from widely reported proceedings.
Hegseth and Iran oversight
·8 minWhat does the public congressional record establish about Hegseth, Iran policy, and the oversight claims, and what remains contested? A signed reconstruction from the widely documented April 29, 2026 House Armed Services Committee hearing.
Named sitting of a Senate committee. Reconstructed from the public hearing record.
Campus antisemitism — Senate HELP, 27 March 2025
·8 minWhat did the 27 March 2025 Senate HELP Committee hearing establish about campus antisemitism post-October 7, and what remained contested?
Ending illegal DEI discrimination — 23 July 2025
·6 minThe Senate Judiciary Subcommittee on the Constitution hearing of 23 July 2025 examining DEI programs and civil-rights enforcement — what the hearing established about discrimination claims, enforcement actions, and what remained contested.
USAID, foreign aid, and speech control — 13 February 2025
·6 minThe Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs hearing of 13 February 2025 examining foreign aid spending and speech-control programs — what the hearing established about USAID activities, witness testimony, and what remained contested.
Erdman hearing
·9 minWhat does the public congressional record establish about the Erdman hearing, and what remains contested? A signed reconstruction from the widely documented May 13, 2026 Senate Homeland Security hearing on CIA whistleblower testimony regarding COVID-19 origins.
Opened published literature — trials, reviews, cohorts. Not a legislative sitting and not a staff report. Same pieces as /writing/evidence.
ADHD
·39 minStimulants reduce ADHD symptoms acutely vs placebo with effect sizes of 0.55–0.84 on teacher and clinician ratings, but the 14-month MTA advantage disappeared by 36 months, long-term functional outcomes do not differ by initial treatment assignment, and parent-teacher rating disagreement is not measurement error—it reflects situation-specific behavior across settings.
ADHD Medications and the Evidence
·43 minGuanfacine and clonidine show child clinician SMDs −0.67 and −0.71 (Cortese 2018), but atomoxetine and viloxazine carry boxed warnings for suicidal ideation. Adult lisdexamfetamine Castells 2018 SMD −1.06; bupropion Verbeeck 2017 pooled −0.50 but clinician-only ns. Adult ER-MPH Boesen 2022 investigator SMD −0.42; IR-MPH Cândido 2021 investigator MD −20.70 but participant ns. Adult GXR Iwanami 2020 Japan diff −4.28; child GXR Sallee 2009 LS-mean −5.41 to −7.88.
Adult ADHD and the Evidence
·26 minProspective cohort studies find that childhood ADHD persistence to adulthood is low across named cohorts (Dunedin 5%, Pelotas 17.2%, E-Risk 21.9%), most adult-ADHD cases lack prospectively diagnosed childhood ADHD (Dunedin 90%, Pelotas 84.6%, E-Risk 67.5%), and after excluding substance use and other disorders, fewer than 1% of originally undiagnosed children meet late-onset criteria.
Depression
·29 minAntidepressants work modestly better than placebo, publication bias inflated their apparent efficacy by 32%, and the serotonin-deficiency model lacks consistent evidence—but neither the chemical-imbalance story nor the 'antidepressants don't work' narrative survives contact with the data.
Anxiety
·121 minForty years of looking for a pathophysiology of anxiety — and what the well-powered nulls, demonstrated confounds and outright reversals actually leave standing. Companion to the stress critical review.
Stress, Energy and the Capacity to Function
·115 minWhat the evidence actually supports about how chronic stress degrades energy and functioning — and why the folk model of cortisol exhaustion and depletable willpower is wrong. Companion to the anxiety critical review.
Benzodiazepines and the Evidence
·28 minBenzodiazepines reduce anxiety symptoms versus placebo in short-term trials (SMD −0.58, low certainty), but physical dependence can develop within days to weeks (FDA FAERS: onset 'days to weeks,' withdrawal 'weeks to years'). Hip fracture risk is substantial (RR 1.52 overall, RR 2.40 new users). Dementia association (HR 1.60, observational) cannot establish causation. Among incident users, 39.4% → long-term use; 50% of patients dispensed oral benzodiazepines received them ≥2 months in 2018.
Antipsychotics and the Evidence
·36 minAll antipsychotics beat placebo in acute trials (SMD 0.33–0.88), but 74% of CATIE participants discontinued within 18 months, dose reduction in first-episode patients doubled 7-year recovery rates versus maintenance treatment, and long-term observational data show better outcomes off medication—confounded by selection, but challenging the 'indefinite treatment for all' assumption.
Mood Stabilizers and the Evidence
·30 minLithium and valproate work comparably for acute mania (no head-to-head difference), lithium shows superior maintenance versus valproate, suicide prevention evidence is contested (early meta-analyses significant, Riblet 2022 not significant), lamotrigine prevents depressive but not manic episodes, and the folk models—lithium as miraculous or lithium as toxic relic—both overclaim what opened trials support.
Diagnostic Thresholds, Prevalence, and Overdiagnosis
·29 minADHD prevalence is stable at 5.3–7.6% when standardized procedures are used, but diagnostic thresholds—symptom count, impairment requirement, informant rules—determine who gets counted. The youngest children in a classroom are diagnosed 60% more often than the oldest, not because of neurological differences, but because teachers compare them to older peers. The evidence refutes both 'diagnoses are exploding' and 'diagnoses are fake.'
Placebo, Expectancy, and Unblinding
·31 minRecognizable side effects unblind psychiatric trials: appetite suppression, sleep disturbance on stimulants; SSRI sexual dysfunction. Active-placebo trials mimicking side effects show SMD 0.17 versus 0.39 with inert placebo. Kirsch's severity interaction is real—placebo response drops in severe depression, drug response stays flat. Publication bias inflated efficacy by 32%. Neither 'it's all placebo' nor 'double-blind means the estimate is clean' survives.
Psychotherapy Comparators and the Evidence
·28 minWaitlist controls inflate psychotherapy effect sizes by 50%: depression versus waitlist g=0.95, versus care-as-usual g=0.63. Response rates are modest: 24-42% across disorders. Head-to-head trials show medication 46.4%, psychotherapy 46.3%, mixed controls 24.4% remission. Common factors account for large variance. Treatment differences exist for some disorders, not others. Neither 'huge effects' nor 'just talking to a friend' survives.
Majority or joint staff reports already published as signed analyses.
Antisemitism on College Campuses Exposed — 31 October 2024
·16 minWhat does the Republican staff report on campus antisemitism establish from a year-long investigation, and what institutional questions remained contested?
How Campuses Became Hotbeds — 17 March 2026
·34 minWhat does the Republican staff report on the rise of radical antisemitism establish about institutional, ideological, and financial forces on campus, and what claims remained contested?
The Intelligence Community 51 letter — 25 June 2024
·8 minThe joint House report of 25 June 2024 examining the October 2020 public statement by 51 former intelligence officials characterizing Hunter Biden's laptop as bearing 'classic earmarks of Russian disinformation' — what the majority staff report established about coordination, what remains the minority reading, and where claims exceed the documented record.
Regulator documents and citation-provenance audits.
Public oversight reconstructions that are not a single named sitting or staff report.
CISA and misinformation governance
·2 minWhat the public congressional record establishes about the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency's engagement with election-related misinformation and disinformation governance, and what remains contested between security framing and speech-control framing.
The Disinformation Governance Board
·2 minWhat the public record establishes about the Department of Homeland Security's Disinformation Governance Board—its creation, stated mission, leadership, pause, and termination—and what remained contested between defenders and critics of the initiative.
Critical race theory and the schools
·2 minWhat does the public congressional and state-oversight record establish about CRT in K-12, and what remains a naming fight? Curriculum debates 2020-2023, the evidence documented in hearings, and where both sides diverge without resolution.
Daszak and EcoHealth oversight
·2 minWhat does the public congressional record establish about Peter Daszak, EcoHealth Alliance, and NIH-funded coronavirus research, and what remains contested? A signed reconstruction from widely documented House and Senate hearings on COVID origins and research oversight.
Gender medicine and minors
·2 minWhat the public congressional and oversight record establishes about medical transition for minors—clinical practices, evidence standards, international policy shifts, and contested claims about benefits and risks—and what remains unresolved in the institutional debate.
The WPATH Files, oversight record
·2 minWhat does the public oversight record establish about the WPATH Files, and what remains contested? Leaked internal communications as reported 2024, the institutional response, and where both sides diverge without resolution.
Title IX and Riley Gaines
·2 minWhat the public congressional record establishes about Title IX, women's sports, and Riley Gaines's testimony regarding transgender athlete participation, and what remains contested between competing interpretations of fairness and inclusion.
Progressive prosecutors
·3 minWhat does the public oversight record establish about progressive prosecutors, crime, and charging policy, and what remains contested?
2020 riots and the double-standard claim
·3 minWhat does the public congressional record establish about 2020 riot enforcement versus later protest cases, and what remains a partisan comparison?
NGOs gone wild
·5 minWhat does the public congressional record establish about NGO funding, migration, and government partnership, and what remains contested?
Financial surveillance oversight
·11 minWhat does the public congressional record establish about financial-surveillance and bank-records oversight, and what remains contested? A signed reconstruction from widely documented House Judiciary testimony on FinCEN and FBI access to private financial data following January 6, 2021.
Jerome Powell's 'transitory' inflation framing (April–December 2021) — a modality-shift audit
·18 minPowell's 'transitory' inflation framing across five 2021 FOMC press conferences, audited as a modality shift in public FOMC record. Four transformation steps from April baseline through November definitional retreat to December past-tense reframing, with per-statement Admiralty grading. The *why* (forecast-tracking vs. communication-choice) filed as an open hypothesis pair pending Fed archival release. Records evidentiary grades, open hypotheses, and the limits of analysis.
Race-Based Politics — the bipartisan discourse object, audited
·10 minThe use of racial framing as a political instrument across the full ideological spectrum — progressive, conservative, centrist, corporate — audited as a coordinated discourse object. Not race. Not racial inequality. The machinery that routinely captures both.
The Rhetoric of Preemption — Operation Epic Fury, audited
·10 minThe rhetorical architecture managing the gap between the stated justifications for Operation Epic Fury and the documented evidentiary record — audited symmetrically across all eight actors: the administration, Israel, Iran, congressional Democrats and Republicans, NATO, the Gulf states, and China. Not the war's wisdom. The discourse object that manages its justification.