Essay
Lindsay Clancy — 3 August 2026
On this page5 sections
Frame
This is a signed analysis of the public record for the fifth day of testimony in the Lindsay Clancy murder trial, dated 27 August 2026. Court sat Monday 3 August 2026 in Plymouth Superior Court. Day 5 of testimony. Medical professionals testified. Testimony ended 26 August 2026. Closings occurred 27 August 2026. The jury is deliberating. There is no verdict as of the opened 27 August coverage. This page does not decide criminal responsibility. It does not use private filings.
What the record shows
Judge William Sullivan presided. Prosecutors continued presenting their case. The trial resumed Monday 3 August for the fifth day of testimony in Plymouth Superior Court.1
Dr. Kelly McDonough, an emergency medicine physician at South Shore Hospital, testified. McDonough treated Clancy at South Shore Hospital on 24 January 2023, the night the children died. Rachel Amedee and Meghan Collins, nurses at Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston, were also called to the stand to testify about Clancy.1
Medical providers testified in the trial, with patient information being disclosed under exceptions to HIPAA and state confidentiality laws.1
Contested
Whether Lindsay Clancy's medical providers failed her or she concealed the severity of her condition from them.
Whether she was overmedicated for postpartum depression and psychosis, as the defense argues.
Limits
No official transcript claimed. Testimony reported via press coverage.
HIPAA allows healthcare providers to disclose patients' health information in court proceedings, subject to exceptions.1
Postpartum psychosis as a diagnosis in general is not on trial. This defendant's criminal responsibility is.
No verdict. Jury deliberating as of 27 August 2026.
Sources
Signed.
Paul Stephen Apatheia Labs 27 August 2026
Footnotes
-
Patriot Ledger, 3 August 2026, "Why doctors can testify about Lindsay Clancy's physical, mental health": https://www.patriotledger.com/story/news/courts/2026/08/03/lindsay-clancy-murder-trial-doctors-testify-medical-records-treatment-hipaa-massachusetts-laws/91150770007/ ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4
About the author
Paul Stephen
Founder, Apatheia Labs
Evidence-governed research publication — Prosoche applied in the open.
Read next
More in The Master Pattern- EssaySeptember 2026
Lindsay Clancy — 29 September 2026
Status hearing. Clancy back in Plymouth Superior Court. Judge Sullivan presiding. Pending defense motions: Rule 25 required finding, double-jeopardy dismissal, limited inquiry into Juror Doe. Commonwealth gag-order motion filed Monday. Commonwealth written response to required-finding motion published Tuesday. DA Cruz has not decided on retry as of morning coverage.
- EssaySeptember 2026
Lindsay Clancy — the record and the campaign
Both sides agree Lindsay Clancy killed her three children. The disputed question is criminal responsibility. Sullivan declared mistrial 4 September. Reddington filed Rule 25 motion. Weinberg entered for double-jeopardy. Patrick Clancy 60 Minutes: grief, forgiveness. Limited-inquiry motion into holdout juror; Monday 21 Sept: double-jeopardy dismissal motion. Status hearing Sept. 29: pending motions, gag order, written responses. DA undecided on retry.
- EssaySeptember 2026
Lindsay Clancy — 4 September 2026
Seventh deliberation day. Morning: heated exchange on holdout juror; Sullivan declined inquiry; sent jury to continue. Midday: jury unable to reach unanimous decision; judge about to declare mistrial; Reddington moved for SJC stay; one-hour window granted. Afternoon: Goldblatt filed stay 12:29; hearing held; Wendlandt took under advisement. Court reconvened; SJC denied stay; Reddington further request denied; Sullivan declared mistrial 2:26 p.m. Status hearing Sept. 29. No verdict.